Need Help? Call (877) 512-7305
To view this content you need the latest version of the Adobe Flash Player.
Download the free Flash Player now!
(based on 55 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Feels too small
Feels true to size
70% (14 reviews)
Feels too large
Feels too short
Feels true to length
95% (18 reviews)
Feels too long
80% (16 reviews)
Reviewed by 55 customers
Displaying reviews 1-30
Back to top
Previous | Next »
By Southern Lady
from Glasgow KY
About Me Bargain Shopper, Casual, Classic, Eclectic, Sexy
Comments about Women's Mercer Plaid Shirt:
I stay cold so this shirt is perfect for anyone who wants to be warm. It washes well and is made exceptionally well. High quality material and workmanship makes this shirt a favorite of mine.
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
Comment on this review(earn bonus points)
By Pooh Bear
from San Diego, CA
About Me Eclectic
I was a bit worried when I read the reviews of this shirt. I had to order a large, even though I usually get XL. The large fits perfect! I am 5'10" with a 6'1" arm span and the sleeves are not too short, as I've seen in other reviews. It's very comfortable with plenty of room to move(I bought it for a work shirt).
Love this shirt
from Boise, ID
About Me Bargain Shopper, Casual
I love this shirt! It's great for when I need long sleeves but don't want heavy fabric, and the fit is perfect - casual yet tailored. It doesn't wrinkle or fade like many other Woolrich shirts I have purchased in the last couple years. I wanted to buy another color and am so disappointed it is sold out. I hope you'll be bringing it back.
About Me Bargain Shopper
Fabric disappointing. too thin color good
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
This was a gift for my daughter
By Chloe's Mom
from Woodinville, WA
About Me Career, Casual, Classic
My daughter loved the herringbone pattern in the stripe which made the shirt a bit different! The sleeves were a bit short, but she wouldn't give the shirt up, opting to just 'roll' the sleeves instead as she liked it so much. We both love Woorich's high quality and excellent customer service!
(0 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
from New York
About Me Classic
I returned item
Nice shirt for casual wear
By Cookie monster
from Spokane, WA
See all my reviews
Use for casual wear and horseback riding. Snaps are a plus - they are actually a safety feature around horses. I haven't washed this shirt yet. If it shrinks I won't be able to wear it. Will wash in cold and cross my fingers.
from Bradenton, FL
About Me Casual
This shirt is very soft, the flannel is excellent quality. Very comfortable fit. It is one of those shirts that makes you feel warm and relaxed.
Great Quality! a classic
By cowgirl in Brooklyn
from Brooklyn, NY
About Me Career, Casual, Classic, Sexy
Great quality woven fabric, classic/vintage look. I ordered a lg. , while it is fitted, it is a bit roomy but nicely tailored. I usually wear 8-10, md. may have been better but was anxious to wear, so kept the large.
By the dog lady
from Polson Montana
Love the style, design and fabric of this shirt. Doens't run true to sizing as described in the catalog and I wish is was a bit longer in the body. Most appealing features to me were the body and fabric design. Also loved the snaps, it isn't that often you see snaps in a lady's shirt
from West Texas
I am disappointed. This shirt last year only came in 3 colors, but I got them all and absolutely love them!When I saw it was offered in more color choices this season, I went ahead and ordered a color I didn't have. But, I am not happy with the material this time around. It is different from last seasons shirt; feels thinner, and wrinkles too easily. It's not as comfortable feeling, either. Also, where is the little Woolrich tag in the side seam this season? I see they have the name WOOLRICH stitched on the shirt on the bottom left side, and I do not like this. I wear my shirts out, so do not like wording on the shirt like that. Hope this is not a trend!
Mercer Plaid Shirt Dark Roast
By Plaid girl
from Duluth, MN
I do like these shirts. The only complaint I have is that they do require ironing! The Petite size is good if you have shorter arms. The colors are Tan, Dark Roast, with a touch of Mulberry. Please make more colors in this!
By yoga cowgirl
from Santa Cruz, CA
i am about 5'5", 33" bust and have strong, muscular arms. Usually i fit a size 6 or 8 in most brands. Shirt fits for me are frequently too snug through the armpit/shoulder and too large in the bust. i ordered the medium in this shirt without high expectations and found myself very pleasantly surprised, the arms and shoulders fit very nicely and it's not too large in the bust. The color is really beautiful and the weight of the fabric is medium, not too light but not to stiff. I really like the western sensibility of the pearl snaps. It's also not too short in length. Very nice, I think a great value for the cost.
Nice lightweight shirt
from Hannibal, Missouri
I liked the color and the style of this shirt. It is very lightweight. I didn't like the feel of the material as well as the homespun shirt but I don't regret the purchase. I felt like it was true to size.
New Year, New Colors . . . New Sizes?
I actually loved this shirt last year and got 2 colors when they were on sale. There are new colors added this year and it seems that new colors are new sizes also. The shirt I ordered in the new colors is about 2 inches shorter across the chest - I actually went to a local store and tried on another new color in hopes of making an exchange, but it fit the same. So, I'm assuming Woolrich has given the sizes a complete adjustment. The shirt is great, the sizing is not.
Good but expensive
By Wool rich customer
Good quality but quite expensive.
Very nice shirt!
By Island Girl
from Seattle , WA
I ordered this shirt in both the Oak Leaf and Deep Ruby. While the Deep Ruby is a nice color, I don't care for the white button snaps, which, for me, contrast too much with the shirt. The Oak Leaf is a dark green and black plaid and is quite elegant for a casual shirt. It pairs nicely with jeans, as well as dressier pants. The fit is true to size and the cut is trim and flattering. The fabric is nice; substantial without being thick or stiff. This shirt looks good tucked in or left out. I am 5'9" and a size 10 and the medium was perfect. I'm very happy with this purchase!
VERY nice shirt
from Landisburg, PA
LOVE the shirt! One thing to keep in mind, though: the figure flattering makes it fit snugger than I like. I usually can remove the darts from other shirts but this one has the darts "built in" the fashion which is good as it add to the look. I wear an XL but, due to the above, returned it for an XXL which solved my "problem."
About Me outdoor person
If you like your shirts a little loose, order the next size up. I normally wear a XL, but with the darts built into the shirt, it felt a bit too snug to suit me, so I returned the XL and got an XXL which fits perfectly!
(2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
By Camper Girl
About Me Classic, Eclectic
This shirt looks good in the Bluebell color way, which gave it a cool vintage plaid look. The quality of this shirt was best compared to the other two shirts I ordered. I am a 34 C and a medium was a perfect fit. I like the feel of the fabric, light but quality. The snap buttons and tailoring make it a great shirt.
By Working in style
from Hibbing MN
About Me Casual, Classic
I work in a male environment in and out of the shop & office. I have a hard time finding nice clothes in the stores that are conservative, yet professional looking. I love Woolrich clothes - they are JUST RIGHT!
Love it... but try before you buy!
from cape may, NJ
Bought my first one in a store after trying it on, and loved it so much that I immediately ordered another online - same exact size, just a different color. While I love the color of the second shirt, the sleeves are nearly 3 inches longer & larger around! Body size is slightly larger also, but not nearly as different as the sleeves. Was really disturbed and disappointed at poor quality control and don't know which, if either, was the true size.
By Blue Skies
I love the fit, feel, and look of the fabric. The snap buttons are great. The tail is long enough to stay tucked.
This shirt has a very nice design and a rich color. It is of fine quality and not too thin but of medium-light weight, which is ideal for fall, winter and spring in Maine. It goes well with my brown corduroys. It is comfortable. I found Woolrich.com only recently. Before then, finding such a beautiful and reasonably priced shirt has not been easy, in fact, it has been impossible.
I wish I had two more of this shirt
from Corinth, Vt
I love this shirt
Better than what I expected
from west texas
I ordered two of these shirts because they were on sale and they really looked quality. I knew they would be, having ordered from Woolrich before. But they were even better in quality than I expected and the fit is fantastic. Maybe it's just me. I hope they fit everybody else as well as they fit me. I would not hesitate for pay full price for a shirt of similar style and material. The workmanship, as always, was very nice.
1st time I wore it I got compliments
wear at work for casual, some people may find it too big, but its what an xl shirt size use to be like
Very nice fabric, good fit, well made!
from Hudson, MA
This is a beautiful shirt, and very well made. The seams are all edged for a neat finish. The extra seams in front and darts in back give a good clean line whether the shirt is tucked in or left out.I like the narrow cuff and tortoise shell-like snaps.
MERCER SHIRT-Herb Green
Even though it is not wrinkle free, I like the weight of this fabric. Lighter than flannel, but heavier than some cottons. Good for 3 seasons.
(0 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
Very happy with the product!
from Deep River, Ct
Used the shirt as a Christmas gift.