Need Help? Call (877) 512-7305
To view this content you need the latest version of the Adobe Flash Player.
Download the free Flash Player now!
(based on 378 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Feels too small
Feels true to size
86% (305 reviews)
Feels too large
Feels too short
Feels true to length
85% (187 reviews)
Feels too long
89% (194 reviews)
Reviewed by 378 customers
Displaying reviews 1-30
Back to top
Previous | Next »
Great flannel shirt!
from Boston, MA
About Me Casual, Classic
Comments about Women's Buffalo Check Flannel Shirt:
Most of the comments I had read about this shirt hold true, it runs larger and a bit heavier than expected, however, I kept the L to use for layering and working on a farm. I ordered a M to wear for casual outings. It looks great, it feels great!
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
Comment on this review(earn bonus points)
from Scotia, NY
Great shirt for casual wear. I love it.
Runs large but well made
By Happy Horses
from Penn Valley, CA
This is a beautiful shirt, well made, and the fabric is both soft and substantial. It feels like it will hold up to years of good use. I work with horses and spend most days outdoors all day, so I look for quality products that won't fall apart. It does run large; I'm usually a medium but this was much too big on me. I'm 5'5" and 120#s with wide shoulders. Rather than gamble that it would shrink adequately when washed, I returned it.
nice country shirt
By Linde, the bunnylady
from Salem, NH
About Me Casual, Classic, Trendy
Looks nice with a shirt under it and with a necklace. Love the colors. Looks trendy with jeans. I'm only 5'2 and I like that it's a bit long to cover up pudgy areas. I wear it for everyday and to work. I haven't washed it yet.
About Me Casual
Love the fabric and the color however the sizing is odd. I am usually a medium. The medium has very short sleeves and a huge body, the large has appropriate length sleeves and an even larger body.
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
By Mary city girl living at Green Acres
from Baltimore, Ohio
Very Flattering on my less than perfect figure. I was very pleased with the length as well as the comfort. I like the color and feel well dressed when I am wearing it.
Best heavy weight flannel shirt
from Raleigh NC
About Me Bargain Shopper, Casual, Classic
I have two of the buffalo plaid shirts now. The blue/black and the green/blue/black buffalo plaid shirts--love them both. So warm just buttoned up to wear inside and outside.
Would've loved it if it fit
from Atlanta, GA
About Me Casual, Classic, Eclectic
Love the check pattern of this shirt but the fit was awful. I ordered my usual size and could've easily gone down a size and then some. Wish I could've exchanged it but I ended up returning it due to the fact they didn't have my size. Very warm and cozy material.
Nice heavyweight material
from North florida
See all my reviews
My husband bought me four flannel shirts from discount retailers. They were very thin material, lightweight and not very warm. I decided to order this shirt in place of those four. It cost more, but the quality is outstanding. The pockets design blend with the shirt fabric because they are lined up. The colors are very nice together, and the weight of the flannel is very warm. Recomend! You won't be sorry you bought this. It is a bit loose and unstructured as opposed to a more tailored fit. That is the only reason I gave it 4 stars
By blake the cat lover
from Marietta, GA
About Me Classic, Eclectic
fabric feels great
from Congress, AZ
When I need a shirt for a bit of coolness, this works. I like it for a lightweight jacket & it is sport dressy.
Love this shirt
from Greenwood, SC
About Me Career, Casual, Classic
I love this shirt. I bought the black and white one first. I loved it so much, I ordered the black and blue. I may order the red in a couple of days. I have not washed this shirt yet. I probably won't dry it very long.
Wanted a Flannel Shirt
from Martin, TN
About Me Bargain Shopper, Career, Casual, Eclectic
Wanted a flannel shirt to wear mostly in casual situations. The fit was a little off but then i am hard to fit to clothes. i did love the color and am pleased with the feel of the fabric. Did wear it in the cold weather and it was great but when it warmed up it was almost too warm in the shirt.
from Metro New York
About Me Bargain Shopper, Casual
This is the heaviest flannel shirt I have ever seen. It is incredibly soft and warm. It will be too large when it arrives and shrinks a lot the first time it is washed. Mine needs to shrink a second time. It is bulky and not fitted, so figure flattering is not an option -- but it looks great layered over a turtleneck. The colors are fabulous and not found anywhere else (I have looked).
About Me Bargain Shopper, Career, Classic, Comfort Oriented
I wear it whenever possible, with or without a t-shirt underneath. it's soft, but the right fabric weight so that it is more than just the cheap ones you buy at the stores! The white is not a perfect white, more of a beige. I don't mind at all but others may, but it's a great fit and feels good. I've washed it once and it's fine... the only thing is that I wish it was made in USA. I am 5'5, swimmer/collegiate athlete (135lbs) and i got a Small. Probably could go XS but I felt the small would offer room underneath should I wanted to wear long sleeve underneath.
By pj from TX
from Lubbock TX
About Me Career, Classic
I have this shirt in another color, so felt very confindent getting it in the buffalo plaid. I was surprised, however, that what they called "white" in the plaid was really beige. However, I got over it and really love the shirt!! I have never felt confident enough in the fabric to wash my other shirt, being afraid that it would shrink and then I would not be able to wear it. Based on that fear, I have always had it dry cleaned - and it has stayed shiny and bright - just like the holiday season!!
By Health Nut
from South East, MO
About Me Bargain Shopper, Casual, Classic, Eclectic
A great casual shirt that is comfortable and quality-made. After washing it as described, I found that the sleeves seemed a little shorter. I think overall the shirt shrunk just a little bit... but I noticed the sleeves the most. I still really like the shirt, especially because the material is thick.
from New Market, MD
About Me Casual, Eclectic
Nice shirt, but my daughter and I don't tuck in the flannel shirts. We use for layering and I did not like the short length and boxy fit. Probably good for those that want to tuck in the shirt, but we flannels for layering like a light jacket. I would have liked more length and less boxy/square at the hips. I returned it.
Buffalo Check Flannel Shirt
By Connie, a happy retiree
from Ithaca, NY
This shirt seems warmer than other flannel shirts I have.
Women's Buffalo Checked Flannel Shirt
from San Clemente, CA
About Me Career
I bought the Black and White checkered in small. I used the fitting guide and a tape measure and I also called Customer Service to get some help in the cut of this style. I am 5'5 and weigh 158. This shirt fits perfect...Very Trendy...Get One.
cool shirt, runs a bit large
About Me Casual, Classic, Eclectic, Sexy, Trendy
Really fun shirt...runs a little large but who cares...I love the shirt and love, love, the black and blue color.
I would wear this shirt every day
By Sue from the mountains
from Sevierville, TN
The wonderful buffalo plaid will be just perfect to wear to work in our country store. I can be stylish and comfortable at the same time. And it will be a great shirt to wear while hiking the Smoky Mountains when there is just a little chill in the air.
Very disappointed in garmet
from Nashville, TN
Fabric felt coarse. Stitches in the top stitching were skipped; actually the stitching must have been done as chain stitching and all would have pulled out. I actually marked the loose stitching with a straight pin.
It won't come off til spring!
By AJ the Southern Classic
from Richmond, VA
I've been looking for the blue/green color for ages. Love the feel-really cozy.
Nice Buffalo Plaid
from Orange County, CA
I enjoyed the color and quality of this shirt. I thought it might be a little softer but its a bit stiff. Looks nice and warm.
I really appreciate the material being of good quality and the size being true to size...whew. Thanks for that.
Just what I wanted!
from skiatook, Oklahoma
About Me Career, Classic, Trendy
Ordered this shirt for my Mom for Christmas. She's going to love it! If she doesn't, I will keep it! I love it! The colors are rich and the material is very soft. You can also wear it as a jacket. It's going to feel warm and toasty this winter for her. Buffalo plaid (red and black) is not easy to find, so glad to find one just like she wanted!
A must have!
from the Midwest
Good quality. Feels wonderful. Shipped fast & free!
I will buy another shirt like this!
from panama city, Florida
i love this shirt. I love the color and it is vey soft. I will use it as a shirt jacket.
from Pacific NW
Perfect for the NW weather this time of the year