Need Help? Call (877) 512-7305
To view this content you need the latest version of the Adobe Flash Player.
Download the free Flash Player now!
(based on 34 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Feels too small
Feels true to size
79% (22 reviews)
Feels too large
Reviewed by 34 customers
Displaying reviews 1-30
Back to top
Previous | Next »
A favorite, with stipulations
from LONG ISLAND, NY
About Me Designer-oriented Classic
Comments about Women's Turtleneck:
Let me say that I really love this turtleneck, but I can't give it five stars because there are drawbacks. It shrinks immediately; I always order a size larger because of that. And, it fades. Right away. But, once it shrinks, it fits fine, and though I'm still unhappy about the fade aspect, it's the most comfortable I have found, and the neck stays pretty true to shape. My hope is that the buyers find a better supplier for the material; I really want to buy more.
Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
Comment on this review(earn bonus points)
The PERFECT turtleneck!
By A Turtleneck Lover
from Lancaster PA
About Me Comfort-oriented, Practical, Stylish
I LOVE this turtleneck because of the tight neck, it's good quality material, well made, the sleeves are cuffed, it fits well, washes well, it is warm, looks nice on and it's comfortable! Other turtlenecks are loose and sloppy around the neck, are cheaply made. This turtleneck looks great under sweaters for casual dress as well as for work with a jacket. This is the ONLY turtleneck I will buy and wear from fall until spring! They may be a little higher priced than other turtlenecks, but are well worth the money!
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I did buy more once I tried it.
from Sausalito, CA
About Me Comfort-oriented, Practical
Hard to find a good fitting comfortable 100% turtle neck...good job.
By Quilt Duchess
from Bradford, PA
About Me Comfort-oriented
Just put on my ruby turtleneck this morning and just love it. The neck of the top is especially nice as it doesn't gap and look sloppy like other brands that I have purchased. The shirt is a little long for me but then as I am only 5'2" that's to be expected. I just wish there were more colors from which to choose as I'd buy several more and in fact may jist do so anyway.
from Northern Idaho
About Me Comfort-oriented, Conservative, Practical
These turtlenecks are perfect. A nicely tight yet not constricting neck that will keep me warm while walking my dogs or riding my horse.I only wish it came in more colors (especially navy.)
(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
By I can't remember the nickname I used!
from southern Arizona
About Me Classic Dresser
I bought this turtleneck in black and in an earlier review agreed with what seems to be the consensus on the neck: tight. However, it does relax just a bit with washing. And the neck was clearly not enough of an issue to keep me from buying two more in white and ecru!
from Eliot, Maine
About Me Casual Dresser
Looks great under sweaters; I bought it to wear under a Woolrich sweater. Very comfortable, good fit, nice color (red)
would buy again and again
Great service and great quality. Keep the product available.
What everyone says is true
By 13th Jeanie
I am a tall, slim person with a suitably sized neck. I bought a large which fits in every way except that neck: it is indeed too tight. Not a lot too tight but enough to cause me to begin pulling at it after several hours wear. Re next question: I would inspect my friend's neck first!
Just What I Hoped For
from Visalia, CA
The fabric is heavy which makes this turtle neckwarm. The color was exactly as it appeared in the catalog.
from alto, mi
Delivery in a timely manner.
Best Turtleneck on market
By Outdoors a lot!
from Noblesville, IN
I have worn these turtlenecks for more than 10 years and I own over 30 of them. They are the only ones I will wear. I love the tight necks...if it is cold enough to wear a turtleneck (skiing, November Football games, February soccer tournaments and March Collegiate Rowing Regattas) then I want one that will stay up and keep me warm. The reason that I return T-necks made by other companies is always droopy necks. These could be a little longer as some of them have shrunk during drying and tend to come out of my jeans when tucked in leaving me with a cold lower back.
almost perfect turtleneck
By Marian the librarian
from Buffalo, NY
The turtlenecks with the label written in script are excellent; those with the label in block letters are inferior.
"The BEST turtleneck made!!"
By Warm and Cozy Patty
from Newton, MA
About Me Trendy/Stylish Dresser
I wear one every day. It keeps me warm and cozy. I absolutely love it. Please continue to keep making it!!!
from Bethlehem, PA
Feels good next to the skin
Exactly what I expected!
By Jules at work
from Milwaukee, WI
I bought serveral of these. They are exactly what I had been searching for. Fits great. Neck holds shape and is not too loose or tight. Color is crisp. Fabric is thicker for cooler weather, but not too thick. Stitching is tight. Great quality turtleneck. Others I have tried tend to streach out as the day goes on. These don't.
ok but not perfect
from Washington DC
About Me Comfort-oriented, Conservative, High-end shopper, Practical
great turtleneck, but too tight around the neck
definitely buy another
from Marilla, NY
About Me High-end shopper, Stylish
I love a turtleneck that is tight in the neck and doesn't constantly fall down and the Woolrich product delivered that.
Way too big for an extra small!
from New York
About Me Conservative, I am 125lbs at 5ft 5in, Practical, Stylish
I was really disappointed that this shirt seems more like a mens small that a ladies extra small.
Size runs large
See all my reviews
[...] I returned this shirt because the fit is too large.
I have 5 of these tutlenecks.
About Me Comfort-oriented, Conservative, High-end shopper, Practical, Stylish
Everything is good. Good product.[...]
Fundamentally a good product except
By Old Bag
from Ann Arbor, MI
I would like to rate it higher except for the neck problem.
Just what I wanted!
About Me Practical
Nice material. Not thin and cheaply made like others I've bought from the other 'outdoor' companies. Comfortable fit. Layers well.
My favorite turtleneck!
from Philadelphia, PA
About Me Comfort-oriented, Stylish
I love this turtleneck top! It fits better than any other turtleneck I've tried. I especially like the cuffed sleeves.
(0 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
By wrinkled kid
from St Johnsbury, VT
I ordered 5 turtlenecks. The other 4 were superb. This one is horrible. The material is flimsy and definitely NOT 100% cotton. The label is sewn in, not printed on like the others. The cuffa are loose and stretchy, where the others are tight and springy. I don't know what happened, but there's something in the wod pile. But I don't want to return the whole order and wait some more. The color was ecru.
from Riverside, CA
Great turtleneck, love the color it looks fabulous with the Sheep sweater I ordered.
I like this turtleneck!
By Cape Rabbit
from Stow, MA
This is exactly the turtleneck I've been looking for! The neck doesn't droop and the sleeves are long enough to cover my wrists. Nice fabric, not too heavy to be bulky and not too thin. The neck is snug without being constricting and I prefer a banded sleeve over hemmed. I'll be purchasing more colors!
Too tight in the neck
from Eastern Tennessee
Could barely get it over my head and too tight at the neck. Returned it.
By fit and slender
from denver, co
I am aware that sizing standards have changed due to our overweight society; but in no universe can this really be an 'XS' size.